Worried About the September Effect? Here’s What History Tells Us About Investing During What’s Generally Been the Worst Month for Stocks.

The S&P 500‘s performance in recent years and recent weeks has offered investors reason for optimism. Over these past few years, the famous benchmark has soared, led by companies involved in the high-growth artificial intelligence (AI) story. These tech giants, from Nvidia to Alphabet, have delivered revenue growth thanks to their AI investments and say this opportunity is far from over.

In more recent times, investor interest has broadened into other sectors, from healthcare to consumer-oriented stocks. And better-than-expected second-quarter earnings reports from a great majority of S&P 500 companies have reinforced this momentum. About 87% of companies reported positive earnings per share surprises, while 77% reported positive revenue surprises, according to the FactSet Earnings Insight newsletter.

All of this has helped the benchmark climb — even amid headwinds such as rising inflation and uncertainty about when the Federal Reserve will move on interest rates. Now, however, in the early trading days of September, some investors might be thinking more about the headwinds than the tailwinds. That’s because of the September Effect. Let’s check out what history tells us about investing during what’s generally been the worst month for stocks.

Image source: Getty Images.

More often lower than higher

First, let’s start by considering the phenomenon known as the September Effect. Over time, the S&P 500 has often declined in September. In fact, since 1928, it’s the only month in which the benchmark has ended lower more often than higher, according to Citadel Securities. And over that time period, the index declined an average of 1.1%, Citadel’s report showed.

What’s the reason for this movement? No one has identified one clear explanation. Some suggest that institutional investors, aiming to lock in profits at the end of the quarter in preparation for year-end, may contribute to it. Others say that the simple idea of a weak September pushes investors to hit the “sell” button, and this keeps the cycle going.

In any case, September declines, when they do occur, aren’t linked to one specific, recurring event. And that means there isn’t really a reason to avoid stocks this month. Still, why invest right now if you know there’s a good chance that you may finish the month with a decline? Let’s consider what history has to say.

The worst September performances

Over the past decade, the worst September performances were the following:

The other September performances throughout this period were either positive or little changed.

Now, in the chart below, let’s take a look at the overall performance of the S&P 500 index from September 2020 through today. We can zoom in to look at the general trend after the September weak periods, and we can consider the entire 10-year time frame.

^SPX data by YCharts

From both perspectives, history tells us that those who invested in September actually scored a win over the mid-to-long term. So, even if investors experienced a September dip, their gains over a number of months and years more than compensated for the September Effect.

Now, you might ask: Wouldn’t it be a better idea to wait out this month and invest at the start of October? Not necessarily, and here’s why. First, it’s impossible to time the market and get in at the very lowest point. Second, even if you could time the market, it wouldn’t make a huge difference in your returns over the long term. Finally, if you wait to invest, you could miss out on a great opportunity — for example, a stock trading at a bargain today may no longer be a bargain a month from now. It’s important to invest throughout investment cycles and avoid focusing on near-term headwinds.

All of this means that, even though stocks often slip in September, the best thing you can do is keep investing in quality, reasonably priced stocks. History shows us that, overwhelmingly, investors who ignore the September Effect and continue investing score a win over the long run.